Scheduler Enhancement

[derekb]

It would be nice if I could pause a show that is running, run a sequence, then have the scheduled show pick right back up. Maybe have some options for continue, like "continue where show left off", "continue at point in time", "run the entire show even if it goes over on time", "continue running show and stop at scheduled time off". What I am wanting to do is in the event that traffic gets out of control or visitors are not following the rules to be able to stop the show and run a sequence about traffic or rules, then have the show continue.

[kevinp]

The scheduler portion of xLights has not been touched in a couple years.  The developers pick and choose what they want to create and/or enhance within the program.  I believe they all use the Falcon Pi Player to schedule and run their shows, so I doubt any of the current developers will enhance the xLights scheduler.  But you never know.

[tindivall]

The scheduler portion of xLights has not been touched in a couple years.  The developers pick and choose what they want to create and/or enhance within the program.  I believe they all use the Falcon Pi Player to schedule and run their shows, so I doubt any of the current developers will enhance the xLights scheduler.  But you never know.

True enough, but this is the Enhancement Request section so as good place as any to ask for scheduler enhancements!


I would like to 2nd the OP's post!

I also recently learned about the MIIP program for LOR that allows visitors watching the show the ability to control which song plays next in the show, that would be a neat feature to look into someday!

[Gilrock]

Yeah good luck with those requests.

[dkulp]

Honestly, I've debated completely removing the entire scheduler code...

[keithsw1111]

I agree dan but I think we still need a scheduler. I just want to see it separate so it doesn't clutter up XLights. Challenge is I also don't want to have to double maintain a bunch of code as well.

[Dave Nibeck]

I would vote to leave the scheduler. Makes for a great backup option just in case.

Sent from my Nexus 6P using Tapatalk

[tindivall]

Yeah good luck with those requests.

Such a wonderful ray of sunshine.

Honestly, I've debated completely removing the entire scheduler code...

While you and others may not use it there are those who do, myself being one.  I would request that it not be removed.

[dkulp]

FYI:  The scheduler is the main reason we still have the "Tab" Window.   If it was removed, the "setup" stuff would go into a dialog of some sort, the Layout stuff would go into a separate floatable window and the space for the tabs could be reclaimed.   The problem is that much of the scheduler code is tied directly to which tab is "active".  Thus, doing any more tab reduction stuff requires completely re-doing a ton of scheduler code.  Since none of the devs actually use the scheduler (and thus wouldn't even know how to start testing any changes), we all kind of don't want to touch it.   

[tindivall]

FYI:  The scheduler is the main reason we still have the "Tab" Window.   If it was removed, the "setup" stuff would go into a dialog of some sort, the Layout stuff would go into a separate floatable window and the space for the tabs could be reclaimed.   The problem is that much of the scheduler code is tied directly to which tab is "active".  Thus, doing any more tab reduction stuff requires completely re-doing a ton of scheduler code.  Since none of the devs actually use the scheduler (and thus wouldn't even know how to start testing any changes), we all kind of don't want to touch it.

I wonder then if it would be possible to make the scheduler its own program in some way.. this way would allow those that don't want it to not have to download and those that do run it along with xlights.   I am not sure where / how to access the code to even begin looking into it.  I haven't coded in 15 years so not sure what / if any help I could be but I wouldn't mind looking at it.

[sean]

A little History:

2010: xLights was created as a scheduler in 2010 by Matt Brown. He did this because of lag playing his LOR sequences.
2013: Matt Brown takes my Nutcracker php code, rewrites into C++ and creates xLights 3.x. Now xLights is a scheduler AND a sequencer. User interface is like an excel spreadsheet
2014: Matt Brown gets hired by LOR, he exits the xLights development team.
2015: xLights 4.x comes out. User interface is like a video editor. Drop effects on model lines.
xLights is a Scheduler and a Sequencer. scheduler code is still vintage 2012. All work is focused on the Sequencer side of xlights.

No one has touched the scheduler since 2012. I last used xLights scheduler in 2012. Since 2013 all my shows run on FPP. We have lots of stuff we all might put into xLights, the scheduler is very low priority. If you know a developer that might want to work on this, please have him contact me.

No windows based scheduler will ever have the abilities that the Linux based FPP has. Peripherals? hundreds available for raspberry pi. Linux has less lag than windows. We have had a dedicated person working on the FPP scheduler since 2013 (first dave pitts, the original author of FPP and then Capt Murdoch). 4 Years of development just on the scheduler. We can never match that kind of investment.

We are working to integrate xLights to FPP even more. Define stuff in xLights, press a button and FPP gets updated.

The xLights team are a group of developers who take time from family to develop this application for themselves and our community. I appreciate all of the hundreds, thousands of hours that have been given to this project.

So, please make enhancement requests. You never know when a developer will agree and take up the task. Working on the scheduler is just going to be very low priority since every developer has been running their show on FPP's for years.

[Gilrock]

Enhancements posted on the forum just get buried and forgotten about anyways.

[Phrog30]

What Gil is saying is to post enhancements here,
https://github.com/smeighan/xLights/issues



Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk

[ozaz]

or, if inclined, add enhancement ideas to this thread as well https://auschristmaslighting.com/forums/index.php/topic,9491.0.html

[CaptainMurdoch]

One path forward may end up being a way to run FPP under Windows.  We are already contemplating distributing an x86 version of FPP that could be installed in a VM or on bare hardware.  Another less likely option is a version of FPP that runs under Cygwin or something similar.  If we get to this point, potentially xLights could include a version of FPP for the scheduler/player portion.  There are several ways we could have xLights drive pixel data to FPP during sequencing to allow viewing the sequence on the lights.