James, you rock. Color wash worked perfectly. That's exactly what I wanted.
For future reference to anyone looking for the same thing. I changed the second layer from a morph effect to a color wash effect, unchecked "Entire Model" and the set the Y coordinate accordingly to the level I wanted it. If you wanted to go horizontal then change the X coordinate instead of the Y. Also, I had to change the layer from "2 is Unmask" to "2 is Mask."