I would love to help, but I'm not sure I understand exactly what you've posted. Let me see if I understand:
You added a 4th Alphapix controller and the output you are getting is incorrect?
If that's the case, do all the props come on correctly when you put the Alphapix in Test mode?
Almost all the errors I have seen troubleshooting shows this year have been in the Networks setup in xLights and/or the universe setup in the controllers. If you would post a pic of your xLights networks setup and pics of your Alphapix setup pages I can help troubleshoot.