Crash 4.1.1

[Phrog30]

I created a simple sequence for testing.  If I double click in the sequencer grid, the app will crash.  After looking around, it only happens when clicking outside of a timing mark.  So, if I have no timing marks, double clicking anywhere in the grid will cause a crash.  If I have timing marks, it will only crash if I click outside (to the right) of the last mark. 


[attachment deleted by admin]

[Gilrock]

And this didn't happen in the last version?

[Phrog30]

I don't know. I could install an earlier version and try.

[Gilrock]

That's up to you.  I can test it out either way but not till tonight.  It does make it easier when problems are posted for us to know if its a problem that just changed in the last release.

Hmm...just a quick browse of the code and we don't even define an event handler for double-click so the grid shouldn't be capable of receiving that event.  Only the waveform currently processes a double-click.

[Phrog30]

Installed 4.0.35, it was fine. Installed 4.1.0, it crashed. So, the last 2 releases.

[Phrog30]

I'm sorry, it does it on a single click as well. So I guess not specific to double click.

[Gilrock]

Ok then it must be the new logic trying to figure out where you selected in the grid.  It's failing because there is no timing effect above your click.

[Gilrock]

That's the problem when we do these rapid beta releases.  I think what's causing this crash is due to changes that were fixing another type of crash.

[flyinverted]

Here is what I see when I test

4.01.0   Left click on the sequencer with no timing mark = crash
4.01.01 Left click on the sequencer with no timing mark = no crash
4.01.01 Right click on the sequencer with no timing mark = crash

[Gilrock]

Yeah I did a checkin last night before this release that I thought fixed the crash when left clicking in the grid with no timing mark.  When you reported the right click problem last night I couldn't repeat it so I thought those other changes I checked in after that had fixed it.  Usually I find people don't give me enough details when they talk about problems.  Thinking back I created a new sequence and right clicked in the timing row which didn't crash.  Left click was causing a crash so I fixed that one.  Since you are saying right click is still crashing I can only guess that maybe you added a model and are right clicking there.

[sean]

i cant seem to duplicate this. i have no timing marks, 80 models and carol of the bells.mp3

i click and double click all over the place, no crash.

could you film your screen with your phone and post the video someplace? That usually helps us see exactly how to duplciate what you do

[Phrog30]

Gil, were you able to duplicate?

[Gilrock]

Sorry gotta finish my day job....can't test till tonight.

[Phrog30]

No problem, just curious. I won't be able to make a video for a few days.

[flyinverted]

Here's the video. All clicks were with the left mouse button. Sean, I used your setup.

http://stevesimages.com/xl4/xl4-click-crash.mp4

I know.. there's absolutely no valid reason to click on an empty panel because there's nothing you can do there.